Think back on the three oral papers we heard this week. Choose one: do you agree with the thesis? Disagree? Choose a position and offer additional textual evidence for your position, i.e. evidence that either supports the thesis or evidence that undercuts the thesis. Consider yourself a jury member who must support either the defense or the prosecution and must have good reason for doing so.
Posts are due Wednesday, September 27th at 9:00 a.m.
A blog site for Dr. Crystal Kirgiss, English 264, Bible as Literature, Fall 2017 - Fall 2018, Purdue University
9.22.2017
9.09.2017
The Character of God (Blog Post 2)
![]() |
| Detail of the Creation of Adam, by Michelangelo, Sistine Chapel (c. 1508-1512) |
How can a human being characterize God?
Michelangelo's paintings of a powerful old man with wavy grey hair and beard are one well-known attempt.
God is powerful. God is old. God is grey. God is surrounded by cherubs.
Some people view God as stern, cranky, impatient, petty, vindictive, vengeful, and other pejorative things.
Some view him as distant and disinterested.
Others view him as a hands-off onlooker of human destiny.
Still others view him as personal, patient, and present in human history.
But how does our text, Genesis, actually describe God?
Using the scenes and words of Genesis, develop a portrait of God's character that considers more than simply the surface level evidence. You don't have room to write a book here; you have only several paragraphs to flesh out a rounded description of this major character in our readings. If you focus on only a single characteristic, you will present us with a flat character. Flat characters are not worth our time and effort, beyond saying, "He or she is a flat character. The End."
God is anything but that.
On the other hand, you don't have space to flesh out God's character in all its fullness. Instead, focus your discussion on perhaps two or three characteristics of God, using textual evidence to bolster your discussion. Use simple parenthetical citations noting both chapter and verse, e.g. (45:9). Paint for us a portrait of God that goes beyond both Michelangelo's grey-haired old man and the various popular notions of God that are too often based on cultural imaginings rather than the written text.
Posts must be thoughtful, substantive, referenced, and articulate. Due: midnight 13 September.
8.25.2017
The Bible Is Lit (Blog Post 1)
![]() |
| Detail of Noah's Ark - from MS Additional 18850 (Beford Hours) folio 16v. (British Library) |
Questions like that are impossible to answer - they are vast and vague and very *yawn* ho-hum.
Better is this question:
What is it like to read the BIBLE as literature, as opposed to reading other texts as literature? Is it different? How? Why?
Or this question:
What is it like to read the Bible as LITERATURE, as opposed to reading it as a religious book? What adjustments (if any) must you make in your reading/annotating/analytic processes?
Choose just ONE of the these topics (BIBLE as literature / Bible as LITERATURE) to respond to, being sure that you are juxtaposing your answer in a proper manner (Bible vs. other literary texts for option one; Bible as primarily a religious text vs. Bible as primarily a literary text for option two).
To help focus your answer to option one, you might choose one or two other literary texts you've read and are familiar with as your comparative foil. To help focus your answer to option two, you might pick a specific section of Biblical text we've covered and outline the possible differences between a religious and a literary reading.
Posts should be long enough to say what needs to be said without rambling, repeating, or using any foo-foo meaningless filler. You don't need to start by repeating the prompt - just jump right into the discussion. Don't write a paper. Papers are d-r-e-a-d-f-u-l. Write a post - a pithy, engaging, brilliant, clever, insightful, fun post. You do not (and cannot) exhaust the topic. There will be more to say than you have room or time for. Choose a few insightful and interesting points to make. Ready: go.
(Responses must be posted by Monday 28 August at midnight.)
11.30.2012
Is it real? (9)
"Is it real?"
That's the question children ask when they read or hear a story.
For grown-ups (which is not necessarily a better or richer stage of life than childhood) the question becomes, "Is it true?"
We all know that Smaug isn't real (or do we...?), but could he possibly by true? That is, is Smaug a dragon as dragons should be, a monster with meaning, an enemy that must be carefully considered?
Some readers - including me - would argue that The Hobbit is TRUE even if it is not REAL. One thing that makes The Hobbit true for me is the scene between Gandalf and Beorn. Gandalf's clever manipulation of the dwarves' entry, his ability to string Beorn along with a stop-start-stop-start narrative, his wit in choosing just the right word to spin things his way - these are all things that I've seen in "real" life. The strategy, tone, and style are all familiar in their own way.
Is The Hobbit true for you? Why or why not? Please steer clear of simplistic generalizations: "I just really love it, you know?" Provide a clear example and explanation for your judgment. And avoid using broad examples that can't be pinned down. Pick a specific character, scene, conversation, setting, or description, and then break down for us how that example = true.
Comments are due by MIDNIGHT, MONDAY 3 DECEMBER.
That's the question children ask when they read or hear a story.
For grown-ups (which is not necessarily a better or richer stage of life than childhood) the question becomes, "Is it true?"
We all know that Smaug isn't real (or do we...?), but could he possibly by true? That is, is Smaug a dragon as dragons should be, a monster with meaning, an enemy that must be carefully considered?
Some readers - including me - would argue that The Hobbit is TRUE even if it is not REAL. One thing that makes The Hobbit true for me is the scene between Gandalf and Beorn. Gandalf's clever manipulation of the dwarves' entry, his ability to string Beorn along with a stop-start-stop-start narrative, his wit in choosing just the right word to spin things his way - these are all things that I've seen in "real" life. The strategy, tone, and style are all familiar in their own way.
Is The Hobbit true for you? Why or why not? Please steer clear of simplistic generalizations: "I just really love it, you know?" Provide a clear example and explanation for your judgment. And avoid using broad examples that can't be pinned down. Pick a specific character, scene, conversation, setting, or description, and then break down for us how that example = true.
Comments are due by MIDNIGHT, MONDAY 3 DECEMBER.
11.11.2012
Read vs See (8)
In his essay "On Fairy Stories," Tolkien argues that a fantasy subcreation - a Secondary World - is best experienced as text. That is, it should be read, not viewed.
So then books beat out dramas and movies. For fantasy, at least. In a visual world such as ours, that's a strong stance to maintain.
Do you agree? Do you disagree? (It's totally fair to disagree. Tolkien was a genius in many ways. That doesn't mean he was right about everything.)
Tell us why you think Tolkien is right or wrong about fantasy in written form versus fantasy in visual form. Provide a concrete example. Don't fall back on "I just like movies better" or "books are the best." Such statements say nothing at all of substance. (We've had enough of that in this election year, don't you think?)
Your example need not be of a fantasy that exists in both written and visual form. Many fantasy books haven't been adapted for the screen, and many cinematic fantasies did not start as written stories. Whatever your example - movie, book, or both - give us some specific reasons for how it influences and supports your opinion of Tolkien's thesis.
Comments are due by MIDNIGHT, THIS FRIDAY 16 November
So then books beat out dramas and movies. For fantasy, at least. In a visual world such as ours, that's a strong stance to maintain.
Do you agree? Do you disagree? (It's totally fair to disagree. Tolkien was a genius in many ways. That doesn't mean he was right about everything.)
Tell us why you think Tolkien is right or wrong about fantasy in written form versus fantasy in visual form. Provide a concrete example. Don't fall back on "I just like movies better" or "books are the best." Such statements say nothing at all of substance. (We've had enough of that in this election year, don't you think?)
Your example need not be of a fantasy that exists in both written and visual form. Many fantasy books haven't been adapted for the screen, and many cinematic fantasies did not start as written stories. Whatever your example - movie, book, or both - give us some specific reasons for how it influences and supports your opinion of Tolkien's thesis.
Comments are due by MIDNIGHT, THIS FRIDAY 16 November
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



