10.21.2012

Tombs in Context (7)

The Tombs of Atuan is hard to pin down. What exactly is it? What is it doing? What is it saying? Where is it going?

All of those questions defy simplistic answers, which perhaps explains in part why the book is beloved by so many readers and esteemed by so many critics.

One way of beginning to answer these questions is to consider Tombs alongside others texts. Sometimes we can only see what something is and what it's doing in light of something else.

Identify a parallel between Tombs and one of our previous novel-length texts (A Wrinkle In Time, Out of the Silent Planet, The Silver Chair). These can range from a character to a plot element to a motif to a specific scene to a phrase to any other textual or authorial detail. Briefly summarize the comparison (providing page references for each) and then talk about how the similar elements shed light on Tombs (and perhaps the other text, too), either by clarifying, narrowing, or enriching your understanding of and engagement with the story (or stories).

Comments are due by noon on MONDAY, OCTOBER 22nd.


10.03.2012

The Joy of Re-reading (5)

There's no denying that Puddleglum is one of Lewis's most endearing characters. His delightful pessimism is just one reason that many readers return to The Silver Chair over and over again - they enjoy being in his company, listening to his morbid observations, and inwardly chuckling at how very, very wrong he is in most cases.

Re-reading is an interesting phenomenon. What motivates us to read something that no longer offers the element of surprise or suspense or novelty or newness?

Tell us what book (or series) you've re-read and then offer a thoughtful reason for your decision to do so (beyond "I really liked it"). Then tell us how the second reading experience was different from the first. Did you react differently? Notice different plot elements? Pay more attention to things previously overlooked? Enjoy it more? Enjoy it differently?

Since your chosen book is unlikely to be one of our course texts, you don't need to cite pages or include specific quotes, but include enough details to make your point clearly. Avoid broad generalizations (which are such a bore to read and say nothing in the end except blahblahumblahblahwellblahblaherblahblah). "I noticed more scenery details" is one such yawner-of-a-statement. 

If you have never re-read a book, tell us what book you might consider re-reading and why, based on our classroom discussions about fiction, narrative, characters, donegality, and more.

Comments are due by midnight on SUNDAY, OCTOBER 14th.

9.22.2012

Audience awareness (4)

Map of Jill, Eustace, and Puddleglum's journey.





In terms of age, the intended audience for The Silver Chair is arguably quite different than for Out of the Silent Planet, even though there are likely just as many (or more) adults who read (and reread) Silver Chair as there are children.

Lewis was very aware of his audience. As you're reading SC, what do you notice about the narrative tone, style, and structure that points to this awareness? Specifically, how can you tell (assuming you can tell) that he was writing for a young audience? Please don't point out the obvious (the protagonists are children; the story is full of fairy-tale elements; there are colored pictures; etc.). Rather, point to a specific moment or scene or description or conversation (or whatever) in SC that illustrates this narrative awareness and then, if possible, tell us how Lewis dealt with the same type of moment or scene or description or conversation differently in OSP. 

Comments are due by noon FRIDAY 28 SEPTEMBER.








9.14.2012

Timeless terseness (3)

Out of the Silent Planet is full of terse and pithy phrases that extend far beyond their immediate context and even, in some cases, far beyond the book itself. For example:

"You cannot see things till you know roughly what they are." (43)

"Small claims must give way to great." (29)

"The love of knowledge is a kind of madness." (56)

"A pleasure is full grown only when it is remembered." (74)

This is just a tiny sample of worthy phrases.

For this post, find one such phrase (be sure to include page number) and give its immediate contextual meaning, then discuss how its larger meaning extends to other parts of the text and even to life beyond the text. 

You could write entire books on many of these phrases - but you have only one blog post. Be precise, concise, organized, and economical with your writing. Don't waste any words on vague generalities or meaningless intro sentences. Jump right into the task at hand and say something insightful and interesting.

Some rules:

1. You may use one of the phrases listed above if you'd like. 
2. Phrases may be used no more than FIVE times each, so pay attention to previous posts.
3. Comments are due by NOON next Thursday, Sept. 20.

9.09.2012

Show (and so tell) (2)

C.S. Lewis believed that a good author must use an economy of words (nothing extra), must be diligent about accuracy of vocabulary (use the word that conveys the exact meaning), and must show beauty / sublimity / ferocity / etc. rather than simply saying "The sky was beautiful" or "The heavens were sublime" or "The dragon was fierce."

Boring. Blah. Ungood. 


Lewis shows us countless things in Out of the Silent Planet - the personalities of the main characters, the overwhelming heavens, the sublime landscape, and more.

Find a specific moment in the text when Lewis 'shows' us something about either a character or a setting. Be sure to include the phrase from the text (referenced with page number) and then tell us (...yes, it's okay to tell us...) what exactly that reference shows us. 

Comments are due by this Thursday (9-13) at noon.